1. Concept Overview
Interference is a phenomenon that occurs when two or more coherent waves superpose at a point in space. As a result:
- At some points, wave amplitudes add up → bright fringes (constructive interference)
- At some points, wave amplitudes cancel out → dark fringes (destructive interference)
This sometimes gives the impression that energy disappears in dark fringes, but it does not.
The energy is re-distributed — more energy goes to bright fringes.
So, total energy remains conserved.
2. Mathematical Discussion
Let two coherent light waves be represented as:
[E_1 = E_0 \sin(\omega t)]
[E_2 = E_0 \sin(\omega t + \phi)]
Resultant electric field at any point:
[E = E_1 + E_2] [= E_0(\sin(\omega t) + \sin(\omega t + \phi))]
Using trigonometric identity:
[E] [= 2E_0 \cos\left(\dfrac{\phi}{2}\right)\sin\left(\omega t + \dfrac{\phi}{2}\right)]
Intensity:
[I \propto E^2] [\Rightarrow I = 4I_0 \cos^2\left(\dfrac{\phi}{2}\right)]
Where:
- [
I_0 \propto E_0^2
]
For bright fringe:
[\phi = 2n\pi] [\Rightarrow I_\text{max} = 4I_0]
For dark fringe:
[\phi = (2n + 1)\pi] [\Rightarrow I_\text{min} = 0]
Although intensity becomes zero at dark fringes, the increased intensity at bright fringes compensates — hence energy remains constant.
3. Key Ideas
| Property | Bright Fringe | Dark Fringe |
|---|---|---|
| Phase difference | [2n\pi] | [(2n+1)\pi] |
| Resultant intensity | [I_\text{max} = 4I_0] | [I_\text{min} = 0] |
| Energy | More concentrated | Shifted away |
✔ Interference pattern forms due to energy redistribution, not loss or creation.
4. Conceptual Questions (with Solutions)
1. Why does intensity go to zero at a dark fringe even though two waves are present?
When two equal-amplitude waves arrive exactly out of phase ([\phi=(2n+1)\pi]) their electric fields cancel point-by-point: [ E = E_0\sin\omega t + E_0\sin(\omega t+\phi)=0.] Since intensity [I\propto E^2], the instantaneous field is zero ⇒ intensity is zero at that location. The waves themselves continue to exist elsewhere; energy is redistributed to bright fringes.
2. How is energy conserved if some places have zero intensity?
Energy conservation holds overall. Interference redistributes energy spatially: bright fringes have higher intensity than each source alone, while dark fringes have lower (or zero) intensity. Averaging intensity over many fringes equals the sum of intensities of the separate sources. For two equal sources [I_1=I_2=I_0], spatial average [ \bar I = I_1+I_2 = 2I_0].
3. Why do we use phase difference to predict interference instead of arrival times?
Phase difference [\Delta\phi] directly relates to path difference [\Delta x] by [\Delta\phi = \dfrac{2\pi}{\lambda}\Delta x]. Phase encodes relative oscillation at the instant of superposition, which determines whether fields add constructively or destructively — it is the natural quantity for interference.
4. If two waves have different amplitudes, can intensity ever drop to zero?
Complete cancellation requires equal amplitudes and opposite phase. If amplitudes differ, resultant minimum is nonzero. Using vector addition: [ I_\text{min} \propto (A_1-A_2)^2,] so only equal amplitudes [A_1=A_2] can give zero.
5. Does destructive interference annihilate photons?
No. Photons are a quantum description; destructive interference means probability amplitudes cancel at that point so detection probability is zero there. Energy is redirected — quantum mechanically, detection probabilities are redistributed, not destroyed.
6. Why does average intensity equal the sum of individual intensities?
Instantaneous intensity for two equal waves with phase [\phi] is [I=4I_0\cos^2(\tfrac{\phi}{2})] locally. Averaging over a whole interference cycle or many fringes (or phases) gives: [ I = 4I_0\cos^2(\tfrac{\phi}{2})] [= 2I_0 = I_1+I_2.] So total (time- or space-averaged) energy equals input energy.
7. Can interference change the total power delivered by sources?
No. The sources deliver the same average power. Interference rearranges where power is delivered (space distribution), but the net power radiated (integrated over all space) remains fixed by the sources.
8. How does coherence affect energy conservation in interference?
Coherence (stable phase relation) is required to form steady interference patterns. If sources are incoherent, phases vary randomly and interference averages out; energy is simply the sum of intensities everywhere — conservation still holds, but no redistribution into fixed fringes occurs.
9. Why do bright fringes can have intensity up to four times each source’s intensity?
For two equal waves of amplitude [E_0]: maxima occur at [\phi=0] giving resultant field [2E_0] so intensity [I\propto(2E_0)^2 = 4E_0^2]. If an individual source intensity is [I_0\propto E_0^2], the bright fringe reaches [4I_0].
10. If two waves interfere destructively at one point, do they always interfere constructively somewhere else?
Yes: because energy is redistributed. For stationary coherent sources the interference pattern consists of alternating constructive and destructive regions; destructive spots correspond to constructive regions elsewhere so total energy is conserved.
11. How does adding a phase-shifting element (e.g., glass plate) move energy?
A glass plate changes optical path and thus local phase. That shifts fringe positions: dark regions move and bright regions appear where dark used to be. Energy flows into newly formed bright regions; total energy remains constant.
12. Can interference create a permanent “dark” region with zero energy flux?
Not permanently in free space from continuous sources — dark regions are stationary if coherence is maintained, but energy is not lost; it is absent only at those spatial points and appears elsewhere.
13. Do reflection/transmission coefficients affect interference energy accounting?
Yes. At interfaces some energy may be reflected/absorbed, reducing transmitted power. Interference redistributes what is transmitted; absorption reduces total transmitted energy, but overall conservation (including absorbed + reflected + transmitted) still holds.
14. How does polarization influence interference energy?
Only components with the same polarization interfere. Orthogonally polarized waves do not produce interference fringes; energy simply adds. So effective redistribution requires overlapping polarization components.
15. Is the interference redistribution instantaneous?
Redistribution occurs at the speed of wave propagation — the pattern establishes after waves have had time to reach the observation region and for steady phase relations to form. It is not a global instantaneous transfer of energy; local fields adjust causally.
5. FAQ / Common Misconceptions
FAQ 1. “Dark fringe means energy is destroyed.”
No. Dark fringes are locations of destructive interference where the local intensity is low or zero; energy is redistributed into bright fringes. Integrating intensity over the whole pattern returns the input energy.
FAQ 2. “Interference violates conservation of energy because brightness increases.”
Apparent local increase is compensated by decreases elsewhere. The **total** energy (integral of intensity) is conserved.
FAQ 3. “Only identical amplitudes produce interference.”
No. Different amplitudes still interfere; fringe visibility decreases but redistribution still occurs according to vector addition of fields.
FAQ 4. “Incoherent sources can produce steady interference.”
False. Incoherent sources have rapidly varying phase; any instantaneous interference averages out and no stable pattern forms.
FAQ 5. “If two waves cancel at a point, nothing passes there.”
Locally instantaneous field may be zero, but there is no net “hole” in transmitted energy — energy flows around and concentrates elsewhere; detectors placed at different locations will register redistributed energy.
FAQ 6. “Interference requires the same frequency exactly.”
For stable, long-lived fringes ideally yes (strict coherence). Small frequency differences produce beats or moving fringes; averaging washes out the pattern.
FAQ 7. “Quantum interference violates particle conservation.”
Quantum interference redistributes detection probabilities but does not violate conservation laws — total expected detections equal source emission rates.
FAQ 8. “Adding a screen stops energy redistribution.”
A screen simply samples the redistributed energy. Placing absorbers changes local energy (absorbed), but redistribution among transmitted regions still governed by interference prior to absorption.
FAQ 9. “Interference patterns create energy from nowhere when constructive occurs.”
No. Constructive regions are brighter because destructive regions are darker; the net energy remains the same.
FAQ 10. “Interference is only for light.”
No — interference is a general wave phenomenon (sound, water, electromagnetic, matter waves).
📝 6. Practice Problems (Step-by-Step Solutions)
Q. Two coherent waves each have intensity [I_0]. What are the resulting intensities at:
(a) Bright fringes
(b) Dark fringes
Solution:
[I_\text{max} = 4I_0] [\quad] [\text{(constructive)}]
[I_\text{min} = 0] [\quad] [\text{(destructive)}]
Q. If the average intensity measured across the screen is [2I_0], show that energy is conserved.
Solution:
Average intensity:
[\bar{I}] [= \dfrac{I_\text{max} + I_\text{min}}{2}] [= \dfrac{4I_0 + 0}{2}] [= 2I_0]
Sum of input intensities from both slits:
[I_1 + I_2] [= I_0 + I_0] [= 2I_0]
[\Rightarrow \bar{I} = I_1 + I_2] [\quad] [(\text{Energy conserved})]
Core Takeaway
Interference redistributes optical energy — it does not destroy or create energy.
Result: Bright fringes get more energy, dark fringes lose it.